Supervised practical experiences: not just a checkbox
By Lysette Flores and Charles O. Galbreath
ATS Commission Standards of Accreditation 4.4 (Master of Divinity) and 4.8 (Master of Arts) require
“supervised practical experience (e.g., practicum or internship) in areas related to the student's vocational calling to achieve the learning outcomes of the degree program.”
The Commission’s approach to contextual learning distinguishes ATS member schools from other graduate education by relating the supervised practical experience to student formation and
vocational calling in preparation for serving communities of faith and the broader public. Supervised ministry, covered in Standards 4.4 and 4.8, connects to several other Standards, most
notably Standard 3: Student Learning and Formation. Far from being a mere requirement, the supervised practical experience is essential to students' intellectual,
human, spiritual, and vocational formation. Field education provides an additional mode of pedagogical learning and lets students demonstrate intercultural competency, global awareness, and
engagement (Standards 3.2, 3.3, and 3.4).
Meaningful formation
For nine years, I, Charles Galbreath (coauthor of this article), served as director of field education at an ATS member school. One of the joys I experienced during those years was serving
students from a variety of experiences and stages in their life journeys. Some were recently out of college, seeking to discern their ministerial call; others had served their communities for
more than 20 years; and others were seeking to be hospital or military chaplains, alongside nonprofit leaders. Many entered the field education experience with the mentality that this was
simply something to check off on their road to graduation. What was wonderful to witness was how, through supervised ministry experience, students were meaningfully formed through practice,
dialogue, supervision, and reflection.
Recurring areas of concern
A survey of Commission on Accrediting reports dating back to February 2021 revealed several recurring themes regarding the expectations for supervised practical experiences. Approximately 35
ATS member schools sought to strengthen their supervised ministry programs in the last five years.
The most commonly noted concern among these schools is strengthening the qualifications, development, and evaluation of practical experience supervisors. Standard 4.4 specifically requires
that these experiences be supervised by those who are appropriately qualified, professionally developed, and regularly evaluated.
In addition to many supervisors not being appropriately oriented, trained, and engaged in ongoing development, some schools lack a process for regularly evaluating supervisors or the sites
where students will serve. Meeting Standard 4.4 requires attention not simply to whether supervision is occurring, but also to the quality, preparation, and ongoing effectiveness of those
providing supervision.
Another recurring area of concern regarding supervised ministry has been that the practical ministry component simply did not exist or was not implemented effectively. Supervised
practical experience must be an intentional component of student learning and formation, not merely an informal or incidental experience. Schools should therefore be able to demonstrate
that students have meaningful opportunities to engage in ministry or other relevant practical settings with appropriate supervision and be able to reflect on how their learning can be
evaluated regularly for quality assurance.
Supervised ministry as formation
Beyond the concerns raised through the various Commission reports, recent scholarship in theological field education offers a helpful reminder of why supervised practical experience matters
in the first place.
Two articles speak directly to the work of today’s supervisors and field educators: Lee Beach’s “Surveying the Inner Landscape: Self-Understanding, Supervision and Formation for Ministry,”
and L. Callid Keefe-Perry’s “Formative AI Pedagogy: Designing for Depth in an
Age of Efficiency.” Read together, this research affirms that formation is central, not incidental, to ministry preparation, and that field education helps students understand who
they are as ministers.
Beach argues that effective ministry begins with self-understanding. Who we are profoundly shapes how we lead, offer pastoral care, preach, teach, and collaborate with others. For this
reason, supervision is not simply about skill development but also about helping students understand their motivations, strengths, weaknesses, wounds, and vocational identity. Beach
identifies several practices that supervision and field education should cultivate, including intentional self-reflection, feedback from trusted others, engagement with the arts, spiritual
direction, and counseling or therapy when appropriate. Supervised ministry provides structured opportunities for this kind of formation, which is difficult to achieve through classroom
learning alone.
Beach also describes supervisors as facilitators of reflection and self-discovery rather than simply evaluators of performance. Practices such as reflection groups, case studies, external
mentors, spiritual autobiographies, guided reflection on spiritual gifts, and summative formation reflections give students space to make meaning of their experience. Supervision, in this
view, is an educational practice and not merely oversight. This understanding connects directly to the most common concern identified by the Board of Commissioners and named in the various
interim reports. If supervisors are to facilitate reflection, discernment, and growth, they must be appropriately oriented, trained, and supported in that role. The presence of trained
supervisors distinguishes supervised ministry as a formative educational practice rather than merely a professional internship.
Keefe-Perry addresses a question with which many theological educators currently wrestle: how artificial intelligence can be used without undermining formation. His central argument is that
theological education should prioritize formation over efficiency. AI should extend students’ capacities, not replace the work of reflection and mean making. Even as technological tools
expand, the work of discernment and vocational formation must remain human centered.
To guide these decisions, Keefe-Perry introduces the ANCHOR framework for evaluating AI use, which attends to Agency, Neighbor-Connectedness, Competence, Hermeneutics, Outward Orientation,
and Reflection. For field educators and supervisors, the framework offers a useful lens for considering whether a given tool supports or short-circuits the reflective work at the heart of
supervised ministry.
Together, these articles suggest that the future of supervised ministry may require renewed attention to how reflection is cultivated. Both emphasize intentional structures that support
self-awareness, critical reflection, and vocational identity formation. This is precisely what Standard 4.4 envisions when it calls for supervised practical experience to be an intentional
component of student learning and formation. Supervised ministry, in other words, is not just a checkbox.
Upcoming webinars
ATS will continue to support member schools in supervised practical experiences by offering two webinars on Friday, January 22, 2027, and Friday, February 19, 2027, both at 2 p.m. ET.
Resources for Schools
Lysette Flores is associate director of initiatives
of The Association of Theological Schools
in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Charles O. Galbreath is director of accreditation
of The Association of Theological Schools
in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.